I started writing this entry while it was still unfolding on Twitter, but you know, life gets in the way of finishing stuff sometimes…
The news that @StephenFry, a huge proponent of Twitter, wanted to quit using Twitter because of the “too much aggression and unkindness around” spread quickly past the Twitterati and unto the online pages of the nation’s newspapers.
I love Twitter and look forward to seeing Fry’s tweets throughout the day. I admit, I tend to put people like him on pedestals. When I say “people like him” I mean the modern Renaissance man - funny, intelligent, successful at everything, larger-than-life sort of people. I never had any parenting to speak of and I like to think of my father as an utter dick (to prevent me from using stronger expletives), so I suspect deep down I still crave some childhood hero worship.
I also empathise with Stephen Fry in many ways. Like him I am a long-suffering long-term Mac lover, pre-web geek, and well-known for my bouts with my dysthymia. I wanted to immediately take his side, beg him to stay on Twitter and continue to enjoy interesting snippets from the day-to-day life of Mr. Fry.
I think what happened to Stephen is what I call “being broadsided,” when something comes at you from just beyond your peripheral vision and the impact knocks you off kilter. Like Fry, I battle depression and during particularly bad patches knocking me over takes little effort. Cumulative criticism engenders even deeper despair.
Everyone knows the downside of Internet-based communication. The screen acts as a sort of an emotional screen as well, and things we’d never say to someone in normal conversation we type for our own and others’ amusement with little awareness of the flesh and blood and feelings on the other side of the ascii bridge. Because this sort of refuge provides convenient cover for people suffering from various developmental difficulties and disorders, I’m told by something of an expert, it may hold greater appeal to those emotionally stunted. Admittedly, since I work in IT and used to socialise with people in IT, my point of view possibly poorly relates to others in the non-geek world.
So a twitterer called @brumplum tweeted Fry was boring, and Fry happened to read it. In a depressed phase, feeling sensitive and vulnerable he recoiled, he blocked @brumplum and swore off Twitter. This too makes perfect sense to me.
Poorly developed empathy abounded in my geek world, and situations similar to those experienced between @brumplum and @stephenfry arise often. I especially draw this sort of fire having gotten on the wrong side of a group of IT people coalesced on a once-popular IT mailing list, and occasionally on a corresponding chat room. Once groupthink set in, abusive behaviour towards me became popular comedy amongst some; others lent support but asked to do so anonymously - they use the list for networking and publicly supporting me was often quoted as being “too political.”
During (not necessarily because of) this period, my low-level dysthymia worsened to the point of severe depression. Other reasons included losing two people close to me, one to suicide, my beautiful dog suffering from cancer and a job at Blackberry I can only compare to being a recruit in Deepcut barracks. The abusive treatment further peppered my battle weariness (which is a poor metaphor for severe depression) with flack. Just like Stephen Fry I mustered up the best defence a depressed person can, I tried to prevent further damage by putting the abusers on ignore and / or blocking them. This leads to very weird-looking one-sided conversations on IRC or Facebook at times, but I quickly got used to that. I prefered it to the risk of further psycnological injury while recovering from a very serious battle with clinical depression.
Fry overreacted when he threatened to leave Twitter, but again I understand the instinct. Most depressives I know hide when they feel assaulted by life. And we don’t know how much crap someone with nearly a million followers pulls in on a daily basis.
What @brumplum said to @stephenfry I personally found in no way abusive, I should point out. I generally get comments more along the lines of (well exactly as): !- leica was kicked from #uknot by a***a [in the words of doctor evil: shush. you're hated because you go on like this, you crazy tart]. That was the latest, I don’t really want to look for more.
Fighting severe depression leaves you drained, constantly tired, irritable, and therefore fairly defenceless to attack, whatever the severity. Depression also marks you as a soft target, so, while you spend most of your waking moments staving off physical exhaustion and daydreams of demise, the type of people who need to inflict pain in order to experience the pleasure of momentary power subconsciously seek you out.
Those are the types of people who went after @brumplum and @alandavies1 in the aftermath of the Stephen Fry debacle. Alan Davies defended Fry, as a good friend should, and got flamed for it. @brumplum received rabid and undeserved flames for abusing Fry, who many refer to as “a national treasure.”
Both Fry and @brumplum sorted out their differences quickly, delayed only by Fry’s being on a plane to LA and therefore incommunicado. @brumplum apologised for what he said, and @stephenfry apologised for overreacting. A modicum of communication ended a raging tempest in a twitterpot. Kudos to both of them for being adults. It restores my faith in humanity, as they say, to see people working out differences simply by communicating.
Needless to say the idiots who bullied @brumplum and @alandavies1 continued for days afterwards. I found this to be true of several people in my situation as well. Some people just don’t know how or when to stop lashing out.
Being in a fairly good place and recovering from the depression that plagued me last year, I have the same instinct as @stephenfry and @brumplum, to try to be an adult and hold out olive branches. It’s still a one-sided proposition so far; most of the angry mini-mob who enjoyed kicking me while I was down still enjoy kicking me while I’m up – sometimes overtly but in many very subtle ways too.
Without benefit of the accord @stephenfry and @brumplum arrived at so easily, I try to understand why people need people like me as punching bags. I concluded at some point in the past or the present they are or were punching bags too, perhaps depressed as well, and find myself, over time, feeling sorry for them rather than hurt or angry.






